Trusts and International Tax: 7 Misconceptions to Understand Before Moving Abroad

Trusts are often established to protect family wealth, manage assets and support long-term succession planning. They can also offer certain tax advantages, depending on how they are structured and the legislation that applies.

However, what happens when the people connected to a trust move abroad?

A trust established in South Africa does not necessarily retain the same tax treatment when its founder, trustees or beneficiaries become tax resident in another country. Equally, relocating overseas does not automatically change the trust’s tax residence or remove its South African tax obligations.

Different countries apply different rules to trusts, which can create unexpected tax liabilities and even potential double taxation.

Here are seven common misconceptions worth understanding.

1. A trust automatically becomes non-resident when its founder moves abroad

Misconception: If the founder of a South African trust emigrates, the trust becomes non-resident too.

A trust’s tax residence is considered separately from the personal tax residence of its founder.

A South African trust may remain South African tax resident even after its founder relocates overseas. Its place of establishment and place of effective management are important considerations.

This includes looking at where trustees reside, where key decisions are made and where the trust is actually managed and administered.

Changing the founder’s personal tax residence does not automatically change the trust’s tax residence. The trust may therefore continue to have South African tax obligations.

2. When a beneficiary moves abroad, distributions are still taxed in their hands

Misconception: Income distributed to a beneficiary living overseas continues to flow through to them and is taxed in their hands.

South Africa has traditionally applied a conduit principle under section 25B of the Income Tax Act, allowing qualifying income vested in beneficiaries to be taxed in their hands rather than the trust’s.

However, amendments effective from 1 March 2024 have restricted this flow-through treatment to South African tax-resident beneficiaries.

Where income is vested in a non-resident beneficiary, it will generally remain taxable in the South African trust rather than flowing through to the beneficiary for South African income tax purposes.

This is particularly important for families whose beneficiaries have relocated abroad while the trust remains South African tax resident.

3. Moving abroad means the founder will automatically be taxed on the trust’s income

Misconception: If you establish a trust in South Africa and move to the UK, you will automatically be taxed personally on its income.

Not necessarily. Different countries have different approaches to taxing trusts and the people connected to them.

The UK, for example, has settlor-interested trust rules which can attribute trust income to a UK-resident founder where certain conditions are met. These include circumstances where the founder or their spouse or civil partner retains an interest or potential benefit under the trust.

However, simply establishing a trust does not automatically mean that all its income will be attributed to the founder personally.

The trust structure, the rights retained by the founder and the circumstances of the beneficiaries must all be considered.

4. The same trust income cannot be taxed in two countries

Misconception: If a trust has already paid tax in South Africa, there cannot be any further tax liability overseas.

International trusts can create potential double taxation.

For example, a South African trust may continue paying tax in South Africa while its founder, having relocated to the UK, is also taxed personally on certain trust income under the UK’s settlor-interested rules.

Beneficiaries living overseas may also face separate tax considerations when receiving distributions.

Double taxation agreements and foreign tax credits may provide relief, but this is not automatic. The availability of relief depends on the type of income, the parties involved and the relevant tax legislation.

5. Appointing foreign trustees automatically changes the trust’s tax residence

Misconception: Appointing trustees who live overseas or moving the trust’s administration abroad will remove its South African tax residence.

Changing trustees or moving administrative functions overseas does not automatically change a trust’s tax residence.

The place of effective management remains important, including where real management decisions are made and who exercises control over the trust.

A trust could potentially be regarded as tax resident in more than one jurisdiction, requiring consideration of the relevant double taxation agreement.

Moving assets, changing trustees or restructuring the trust may also trigger additional tax consequences, including capital gains tax.

6. A trust’s tax advantages remain the same regardless of where beneficiaries live

Misconception: A trust established for family wealth planning will provide the same tax benefits even when family members move to different countries.

Trust taxation varies considerably between jurisdictions.

Some countries tax income within the trust, while others may attribute income to the founder or tax beneficiaries when they receive distributions. Additional considerations may include capital gains tax, inheritance tax and wealth tax.

The UK, for example, has specific rules governing distributions received by UK-resident beneficiaries from non-UK trusts. The treatment depends on the nature of the distribution, the underlying income or gains and the beneficiary’s circumstances.

A structure that works well under one country’s tax rules may therefore produce a very different outcome when family members become resident elsewhere.

7. Trust planning can wait until after you have relocated

Misconception: It is only necessary to review your trust once you have moved abroad.

Planning before relocation is important because becoming tax resident in another country can introduce new tax liabilities and reporting obligations.

Before moving, consider:

  • The trust deed: Review the founder’s retained rights, trustee powers and beneficiary provisions.
  • The founder’s tax position: Determine whether the destination country could tax the founder personally on trust income.
  • The beneficiaries: Understand how existing and future beneficiaries may be taxed in their countries of residence.
  • Distributions: Consider the timing and tax treatment of distributions before and after relocation.
  • Capital gains and inheritance: Assess potential capital gains tax, inheritance tax and estate duty implications.
  • Trust management: Understand whether changes to trustees or administration could affect the trust’s tax residence.

Obtaining advice in both jurisdictions before making changes can help identify potential issues and avoid unexpected tax consequences.

A trust needs to work across borders, not just within one jurisdiction

Trusts can play an important role in wealth protection, succession planning and managing family assets. However, international relocation can fundamentally change how they are taxed.

There is no one-size-fits-all approach. The right tax treatment depends on the trust structure, the people involved and the legislation in each relevant jurisdiction.

At SAIL International, we help individuals and businesses navigate cross-border tax matters, providing practical advice to help them understand their obligations and make informed decisions.

Considering a trust or managing a trust with international beneficiaries?

Speak to SAIL International about your cross-border tax considerations and how they may affect your existing arrangements.

Book a free 15-minute consultation or contact us at info@sailinternational.co.

Related Posts

Book a FREE 15-minute call with us